The Case for Christ movie: An atheist wrestles with the evidence

by christiannewsjournal
Mike Vogel plays Lee Strobel

If you’re a committed atheist and your spouse becomes a follower of Jesus, it might just rock your world. That’s what happened to hardnosed Chicago Tribune legal affairs editor Lee Strobel, who marshalled his skills in journalism and law to find out what had happened to his wife.

Strobel’s quest became a bestselling book, The Case for Christ, and now a movie. He writes that Leslie’s 1979 announcement stunned him. He felt “like the victim of a bait-and-switch scam. I had married one Leslie – fun…carefree…risk-taking – and now I feared she was going to turn into some sort of sexually repressed prude who would trade our upwardly mobile lifestyle for all-night prayer vigils and volunteer work in grimy soup kitchens.”

“Instead,” he continues, “I was pleasantly surprised – even fascinated – by the fundamental changes in her character, her integrity, and her personal confidence.” He aimed to investigate faith from top to bottom to see if it made sense.

The film stars Mike Vogel (The Help), Erika Christensen (Frasier, Traffic) and Oscar-winner Faye Dunaway (Bonnie and Clyde, Network). (Spoilers ahead.)


Rigorous methods; avoiding pitfalls

Educated at the University of Missouri School of Journalism and Yale Law School, Strobel determined to use the rigorous methods a veteran journalist and legal analyst would about a court case: sifting evidence, evaluating reliability, considering alternatives. He studied history, archaeology, and ancient literature and interviewed experts.

Strobel wanted to avoid pitfalls he had experienced earlier in his career when an apparently clear-cut court case he was covering had its guilty verdict reversed. In retrospect, he realized he had been viewing the facts through preconceived biases that blinded him from objective evaluation. He determined to study from a fresh perspective the faith he had thought was a fairy tale.

For nearly two years he asked hard questions about source reliability, about Jesus’ life, death and alleged Resurrection, and more. The book and the film present what he discovered, not as academic treatises – though the book is well written for thinking readers, and extensively documented – but in the context of colorful, touching stories about how he wrestled with his findings.


Skeptical, analytical questions

The movie skillfully weaves his skeptical, analytical questions into the fabric of love, pain, sorrow and joy that composed his marriage and family life. A glimpse of what he encountered:

Regarding the source material, he found scholarly support for “the essential reliability of the New Testament documents…their accurate transmittal through history…extensive corroboration by ancient historians and others,” and for the assertion that “archaeology underscores their trustworthiness.”

Regarding Jesus, he found multiple attestations that Jesus claimed deity. Jesus’ “I and the Father are one” New Testament claim is echoed by contemporary friends…and even enemies, who accused him of blasphemy for an assertion they considered outrageous.

Lots of mentally disturbed people believe they are God. Was Jesus one of them? Strobel says Jesus’ discourses display “no sign of dementia, delusions, or paranoia.” Rather they evidence “profound wisdom…uncanny insights…poetic eloquence, and…deep compassion.”

Jesus fulfilled many Hebrew prophecies regarding the Jewish Messiah. Strobel cites Peter Stoner, a mathematician who calculated the probability of just eight of these coming true in one person as one chance in 10.


Empty tomb; a little girl’s wish

And Strobel found convincing evidence that Jesus was executed, buried, and returned to life. The tomb was empty and many eyewitnesses said they saw him alive again, some at the cost of their lives.

Leslie and Lee Strobel

Leslie and Lee Strobel

He concluded, “The atheism I had embraced for so long buckled under the weight of historical truth. …It would require much more faith for me to maintain my atheism than to trust in Jesus of Nazareth!” He invited Jesus to forgive him and become his personal friend in 1981.

The change in his formerly self-absorbed life was so radical that a few months later, his five-year-old daughter said, “Mommy, I want God to do for me what he’s done for Daddy.”

The Case for Christ is a compelling film that is sensitive toward those who disagree and aims to get viewers thinking about matters that can make a world of difference in their lives and families. Well worth seeing.

Rated PG (USA) “for thematic elements including medical descriptions of crucifixion, and incidental smoking.”   Opens April 7 (USA)

Rusty Wright

— by Rusty Wright

Wright is an author and lecturer who has spoken on six continents. He holds Bachelor of Science (psychology) and Master of Theology degrees from Duke and Oxford universities, respectively.

You may also like

© 2023 Christian News Journal | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Developed by CI Design, LLC