Earlier this week, the city of Houston, the fourth-largest city in the U.S., issued a subpoena to a group of pastors demanding copies of sermons that touched on the subjects of “homosexuality, gender identity or Annise Parker, the city’s first openly-lesbian mayor.”
Let that sink in. In America, a city government has demanded that religious leaders turn over their sermons or face contempt of court charges, even possibly jail time.
Words fail me. This is beyond outrageous. John Stonestreet and I—and Chuck Colson before us—have been warning for years that our religious liberties are in peril in every aspect of life. This may be the wake-up call the church in America needs.
Okay, so here’s the background. In May, the city council enacted an ordinance that permitted transgendered men to use women’s public restrooms.
Mayor Parker defended the ordinance as a measure that supported the “Houston I know [that] does not discriminate, treats everyone equally and allows full participation by everyone in civic and business life.”
Missing in that high-sounding rhetoric was any guidance regarding how to distinguish a transgendered man from a guy who simply wants to see women in various states of undress in a public restroom.
In response to this, opponents of the ordinance gathered more than 50,000 signatures to put a measure repealing the ordinance on the ballot. While “the city secretary, who is entrusted by law to examine and certify petitions, certified [it] as sufficient,” the city attorney and the mayor’s office threw out the petitions claiming irregularities. The people behind the petition drive then sued the city.
That’s when Houston decided to play hardball and issued the subpoenas to the pastors. Mayor Parker called the demand for the sermons “fair game,” even though none of the pastors was directly connected to the petition drive or the lawsuit.
A colleague of mine, who graduated from law school and passed the bar, asked “how is this legal?” when he learned about the subpoenas. And of course, he wasn’t alone. Russell Moore, of the Southern Baptist Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission, in a piece entitled “Houston, We Have a Constitution,” wrote that he was “simply stunned by the audacity” of the subpoenas.
As the Alliance Defending Freedom’s Christiana Holcomb put it, “The city council and its attorneys are engaging in an inquisition designed to stifle any critique of its actions. Political and social commentary is not a crime; it is protected by the First Amendment.”
Presumably, Houston’s lawyers also graduated from law school and passed the bar, so they had to know that there was no way this action would stand up in court. So why did they proceed?
They proceeded because their goal was not legal—it was political. The goal was not to prevail in litigation over the petitions but to intimidate their opponents and create what the Supreme Court has called a “chilling effect” on future challenges to government actions by religiously-motivated citizens. The message was “oppose us and we will make your life miserable.”
As I record this commentary, it seems that Houston is re-thinking the subpoenas. But it’s important to note that if they are, it’s only because citizens are crying foul and pushing back—hard. As they should.
That in itself is a sad reminder that the freedom we once took for granted is now up for grabs. And that we can never, ever be silent in the face of this kind of horrendous and utterly un-American intimidation.
Maybe we’ll win this round, but it’s clear that we have a problem—and not only in Houston.
Editor’s Note: According to an amended motion filed Friday (Oct. 17) in Harris County, Texas court, the city’s attorneys will no longer demand “sermons” related to homosexuals, gender identity, or Mayor Annise Parker – Houston’s first openly lesbian mayor.
However, the amended subpoenas do require the pastors to turn over “all speeches or presentations related to the Houston Equal Rights Ordinance” – along with 17 different categories of information – including speeches by the pastors, emails, text messages and other private communications within the church.
— by Eric Metaxas
Metaxas is currently the voice of Breakpoint, a radio commentary (www.breakpoint.org) that is broadcast on 400 stations with an audience of eight million.
Copyright© 2014 Prison Fellowship Ministries. Reprinted with permission. BreakPoint is a ministry of Prison Fellowship Ministries